Balms, Gels, & Lotions for After the Shave: Your Face Deserves a Treat

Shaving is hard on your face. Even with the best safety razor, blade, shaving brush, and shaving soap or shaving cream, daily shaving can take a toll on your skin.  Many of these products, since they do not contain alcohol, can help restore and revitalize the skin.

FREE SHIPPING on orders over $100. See our SHOP NOW page for details.

Browse our selection of Balms, Gels, & Lotions below.
When you click "Buy Now", your selection is automatically placed in your shopping cart so you can continue browsing.

Balms, Gels, & Lotions for After the Shave

Sort by: Product Price Default See details Captain's Choice Bay Rum Aftershave AS079 - Captain's Choice Bay Rum Aftershave is a full-bodied bay rum with a deep amber color and hints of cinnamon and citrus and for once no cloves. How refreshing!   The natural ingredients may settle over time, so you may want to shake it before each use.  It comes in a 4 oz. glass bottle. Ingredients: Pure grain alcohol, witch hazel, rum, essential oils and extracts, glycerin. Made in the USA. Our price: $17.99 Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Buy Now Add to wish list See details Captain's Choice Lime Aftershave AS081 - Captain's Choice Lime Aftershave is lime aftershave made from all natural ingredients. It's pleasant, natural lime scent is long lasting and, due to the added glycerin, the product is modestly moisturizing.  It comes in a 4 oz. glass bottle. Ingredients: Pure grain alcohol, witch hazel, essential oils and extracts, glycerin. Made in the USA. Our price: $17.99 Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Buy Now Add to wish list See details Essential Oil Aftershave Balm - Castle Forbes Collection AS040 - The Essential Oil Aftershave Balms from the Castle Forbes are alcohol free and use natural witch hazel to close the pores after shaving without leaving a sticky residue on the skin. Available in Lavender and Lime Essential Oils and a Cedarwood & Sandalwood Oil blend. Our price: $49.99 Buy Now See details 1445 Aftershave Balm - Castle Forbes Collection AS041 - The 1445 Aftershave Balm from the Castle Forbes Collection is alcohol free and uses natural witch hazel to close the pores after shaving. This combined with the healing properties of pure essential oils, results in a superior quality, moisturizing skin balm. 4.4 fl. oz. bottle. Our price: $49.99 Quantity 1 2 3 4 Buy Now Add to wish list See details The After Shave Balm - 100ml/3.4 oz. - The Gentlemens Refinery AS050 - The After Shave Balm from The Gentlemens Refinery comes in a 100ml/3.4 fl. oz. air tight, pump bottle. It is a revolutionary formulation designed to expedite the healing process, and seal skin from external impurities. Made from 100% natural ingredients, it is paraben and alcohol free. Available in the lightly scented "Standard" with certified organic essential oils and their popular "Unscented" formula. Our price: $39.99 Buy Now See details Aftershave Lotion - D.R. Harris & Co. - 100ml AS020 - Aftershave lotion from D.R. Harris & Co. is a classic English aftershave "splash" containing alcohol. It is available in their top selling classic English fragrance Arlington, their Marlborough scent, their delightful Sandalwood with "Tangy Oils", and their latest offering Windsor. All are in 100ml bottles. Our price: $44.99 Buy Now See details Pink After Shave - D.R. Harris & Co. - 100ml AS021 - The Pink After Shave from D.R. Harris & Co. is a very mild, soft rosy pink lotion for tender skins. Since it contains almost no alcohol, it does not sting and is ideal for use on skins suffering from any sensitivity problems. Available in 100ml bottles. Our price: $39.99 Quantity 1 2 3 Buy Now Add to wish list See details Klar's Aftershave AS075 - Klar's Aftershave comes to us from Germany's oldest soap maker. This is a traditional aftershave splash containing alcohol as well as witch hazel.  It comes in a 50ml glass bottle. Available in Classic and Sandalwood fragrances to compliment their shavings soaps. See "Details" for more information. Imported from Germany. Our price: $29.99 Buy Now See details Blenheim Bouquet Aftershave Splash - Penhaligon's - 100ml AS061 - The Blenheim Bouquet Aftershave Splash from Penhaligon's is a traditional aftershave splash containing alcohol used to refresh and tone the skin after shaving. Men with sensitive skin may like to consider the After Shave Balm which does not contain alcohol. It comes in a 3.4 fl. oz./100 ml  glass bottle. Please Note:  This product has been discontinued in the 100ml size. It is now available only in 200ml.  We only have a few of these left. Our price: $84.99 Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 Buy Now Add to wish list See details Aftershave Balms from Penhaligon's AS060 - The Aftershave Balms from Penhaligon's are scented with some of their most popular fragrances. Currently available are those scented with Blenheim Bouquet, Endymion, and Opus 1870. They comes in a 150ml/5 fl.oz. tube. The Opus 1870 Balm has been discontinued.  We only have a couple left. See "Details" for more information. Our price: $54.99 Buy Now See details Proraso Aftershave - Eucalyptus Oil and Menthol - 100ml. Glass Bottle ***New Formula*** AS076 - Proraso Aftershave with Eucalyptus Oil and Menthol is the classic Italian aftershave from the Florence based company established in 1948. With its distinctive fragrance and cooling sensation, it both refreshes and tones.  Packaged in a 100ml/ 3.4 fl.oz. glass bottle. . These new formulations are an improvement over the old plus they have no parabens, no silicone, and no SLS (Sodium Lauryl Sulfate),  no mineral oil, and no artificial colors. Imported from Italy. Our price: $14.99 Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Buy Now Add to wish list See details Proraso Aftershave Balm Sensitive Skin Formula with Green Tea and Oat - 100ml. Glass Bottle ***New Formula*** AS077 - Proraso Aftershave Balm with Green Tea and Oat is the classic Italian aftershave balm from the Florence based company established in 1948. This is a soothing non-alcohol milk containing green tea and oatmeal extracts.  The perfect product for those with sensitive skin. Packaged in a 100ml/ 3.4 fl.oz. glass bottle. These new formulations are an improvement over the old plus they have no parabens, no silicone, and no SLS (Sodium Lauryl Sulfate),  no mineral oil, and no artificial colors. Imported from Italy. Our price: $14.99 Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Buy Now Add to wish list See details Proraso Aftershave Balm - Aloe and Vitamin E - 100ml. Glass Bottle ***New Formula*** AS078 - Proraso Aftershave Balm with Aloe and Vitamin E is a new variation on the classic Italian aftershave balm from the Florence based company established in 1948. This "protective and moisturizing aftershave balm" is a non-alcohol milk containing aloe and Vitamin E.  Packaged in a 100ml/ 3.4 fl.oz. glass bottle. These new formulations are an improvement over the old plus they have no parabens, no silicone, and no SLS (Sodium Lauryl Sulfate),  no mineral oil, and no artificial colors. Import... Our price: $14.99 Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Buy Now Add to wish list See details Aftershave Lotion - Taylor of Old Bond Street AS010 - Aftershave Lotion from Taylor of Old Bond Street, in five classic fragrances, is a luxury gentleman's after-shave formulated to put the perfect finish on any shave. Each contains essential oils, herbal aromatics, alcohol, and fragrance in a 100ml / 3.3 fl. oz. bottle. See "Details". Our price: $32.49 Buy Now See details No. 74 Traditional Aftershave Lotion - Taylor of Old Bond Street AS012 - The No. 74 Traditional Aftershave Lotion from Taylor of Old Bond Street is one of the oldest fragrances offered by this venerable firm. A floral fragrance with top notes of orange, bergamot and lemon with a background of lilac, jasmine, rose and sweet musk.  It comes in a 100ml/3.5 fl. oz. bottle. Made in the United Kingdom. Our price: $32.49 Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Buy Now Add to wish list See details No. 74 Victorian Lime Aftershave Lotion - Taylor of Old Bond Street AS011 - No. 74 Victorian Lime Aftershave Lotion from Taylor of Old Bond Street is one of the oldest fragrances offered by this venerable firm. A citrus fragrance with top notes of lime on a background of wood and fuschia. It comes in a 100ml/3.5 fl. oz. bottle. Made in the United Kingdom. Our price: $32.49 Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Buy Now Add to wish list See details Jermyn Street Collection Aftershave Lotion For Sensitive Skin - 100ml - Taylor of Old Bond Street ***Alcohol Free*** AS013 - The Jermyn Street Collection Aftershave Lotion For Sensitive Skin from Taylor of Old Bond Street is specially formulated for sensitive skin.  It contains no alcohol and is paraben free.  It's fougere fragrance is said to be allergen free.  Available in a 100ml / 3.5 fl. oz. bottle. Our price: $36.99 Quantity 1 2 Buy Now Add to wish list See details Aftershave Balm & Gels - Taylor of Old Bond Street AS001 - The Aftershave Balms and Gels from Taylor of Old Bond Street are specially formulated without alcohol to soothe the skin after shaving. They contains Aloe Vera and Witch Hazel. Available fragrances include Mr. Taylor, Sandalwood, and Shaving Shop. See "Details". Our price: $22.49 Buy Now See details Jermyn Street Collection Aftershave Cream For Sensitive Skin - 75 ml - Taylor of Old Bond Street AS002 - The Jermyn Street Collection Aftershave Cream For Sensitive Skin from Taylor of Old Bond Street has been specially formulated with moisturizers for those with sensitive skin.  It contains no alcohol or parabens.  All fragrances and other ingredients are said to be allergen-free. Please see "Details" for more information. Our price: $24.99 Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Buy Now Add to wish list See details Bay Rum - Taylor of Old Bond Street - 250ml. AS004 - Bay Rum from Taylor of Old Bond Street is an infusion of genuine bay leaves with rum. It creates a spicy, rich and exotic elixir that can be used as either as an aftershave or a cologne. Comes in a 250ml/8.4 fl. oz. bottle. Made in the United Kingdom. Our price: $34.99 Quantity 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Buy Now Add to wish list